Updated

What investors are saying about the AI trade

We read every post about AI on XRedditStocktwitsYouTube since ChatGPT launched and recorded which side of the trade each author takes.

Nvidia (NVDA) share priceSkepticsBelievers
Believers (green) and skeptics (red) as shares of the engagement on posts that take a side on the AI trade, by month, under Nvidia's share price. Posts that argue both ways are left out: 5% of the engagement in 2026. The latest month is not complete.

The five findings

  • Most investors still believe in the AI trade. Counted by engagement, believers outweigh skeptics about three to one in 2026.
  • Doubt is growing. Skeptics were about two in ten in 2023. In the latest month they are about four in ten.
  • Reddit has turned against the trade. It is the one network where skeptics now lead. X, YouTube and Stocktwits are still mostly believers.
  • Belief in the technology went up, not down. The share of engagement calling AI overhyped fell from 22% in 2023 to 10% in 2026. The doubt that grew is about money: debt, companies that fund their own customers, and spending that may never be earned back.
  • Both sides are arguing about the same stocks. NVDA, MU, GOOG, META, MSFT are among the stocks believers most expect to rise and among the stocks skeptics most expect to fall. The name skeptics talk about most is OPENAI.

What do the two sides say?

Believers, in their words

@RosannaInvests
X
AI isn't a bubble. Bubbles run on stories. This one runs on contracts.
September 2026
u/WePrezidentNow
Reddit r/investing
I work as a cloud engineer and it is blatantly obvious just how supply-constrained the market is right now. ... the risk for these companies is that they underbuild, not overbuild.
July 2026
@bryonseverns5919
YouTube comment
NVidia shopping for AI supplies, is like Florida homeowners in Home Depot before a hurricane. The closer the storm gets, the bigger it gets.
August 2026
AllMarkets
Stocktwits
power is the biggest bottleneck for AI. Can't run the chips if you can't plug them in.
November 2026

Skeptics, in their words

@soham_nayak04
X
ChatGPT: free Gemini: free Claude: free Grok: free DeepSeek: free $725 billion is going into data centers this year am I missing something
September 2026
u/DragonflyEither1484
Reddit r/wallstreetbets
Sir, we've just discovered the limits of artificial intelligence. They're financial.
November 2026
@ersinc9080
YouTube comment
This seems like nineteen ninety nine again. The internet was very successful, but at the beginning, most of the companies in it were not. They failed.
October 2026
squeezehunter8
Stocktwits
There's a massive difference between an AI revolution and AI investments actually generating enough profits to justify their astronomical costs.
October 2026

Do investors think AI works?

Yes, more each year. This is a separate question from the investing one: an author can think AI will change the world and still think the stocks cost too much.

It will change the world

It is useful

It is overhyped

It does not work

What authors say about the technology itself, each view as a share of the engagement on posts that give one, by month. The four add to 100% and share one scale.

How do they feel about it?

Excited
Mocking
Anxious
Greedy
Angry
Afraid
The feeling a post shows, as a share of the engagement on AI posts. About half of posts show none. Each drawing runs from January 2023 to November 2026, a bar per month, the latest solid. All share one scale.

Why do investors believe in the AI trade, and why do they doubt it?

Believers point to demand: capacity is sold out and contracts are signed. Skeptics used to argue about one stock. They now argue about where the money comes from.

Reasons to believe

Demand is real
Suppliers win whoever wins
Electricity is the shortage
It is still early
Big tech wins
Nobody can afford to stop spending
Share of the engagement on AI posts that make each argument. A post can make several. Each drawing runs from January 2023 to November 2026, a bar per month, the latest solid. All share one scale.

Reasons to doubt

China
The spending will not be earned back
It is a bubble
Prices are too high
It is built on debt
Models are interchangeable
Rivals will take the leader's business
Companies fund their own customers
Orders will slow
Not enough electricity
The same measure for the arguments against, on a scale of their own.

Do investors think the data-center buildout will pay off?

Most have said it will, but in the last two months that fell to about half. The buildout is the spending on data centers, chips and the electricity to run them.

It will pay offIt is held back by power, chips or moneyIt is overbuilt
The verdict authors give on the buildout, as shares of the engagement on posts that give one, by month. Months with fewer than 20 such posts are left blank.

Which stocks do believers and skeptics name?

Believers spread their calls across chip makers, memory makers and the big technology companies. Skeptics name two companies far more than any other, and several of the believers' favorites are on their list.

#BelieversShare of believers' stock callsWill riseWill fallPosts
1NVDA
9%
99%1%1200
2IREN
8%
100%0%625
3MU
5%
100%0%631
4NBIS
4%
100%0%450
5AMD
4%
99%1%466
6GOOG
4%
98%2%442
7AMZN
3%
100%0%311
8META
3%
98%2%290
9SNDK
3%
100%0%214
10MSFT
2%
90%10%309
#SkepticsShare of skeptics' stock callsWill riseWill fallPosts
1OPENAI
18%
0%100%238
2NVDA
14%
1%99%206
3SPCX
7%
2%98%38
4ORCL
6%
0%100%82
5MSFT
4%
3%97%57
6META
3%
10%90%67
7MU
3%
7%93%63
8CRWV
3%
0%100%56
9GOOG
2%
16%84%50
10PLTR
2%
19%81%31

The ten stocks each side names most in 2026, ranked by share of the engagement on that side's posts that say a stock will rise or fall. Will rise and will fall split that stock's engagement by direction. Stocks named in fewer than ten posts are left out. Each links to what investors are saying about that stock today.

Which words is the AI trade argued in?

The talk moved from the software to the buildings. Data centers, chips, spending and electricity take up more of it each year.

"data center"
"agents"
"GPU"
China
jobs, layoffs
"compute"
"bubble"
dot-com, 1999, Cisco
"capex"
"hyperscaler"
electricity, grid, nuclear, gigawatt
"inference"
"moat"
"AGI"
"depreciation"
"circular" deals
Share of the engagement on AI posts that use each word, a bar per month from January 2023 to November 2026. Counted on every AI post, not a sample. Each drawing has its own scale, so compare shapes, not heights.

What do the new phrases mean?

These phrases were rare or absent in the posts before 2025.

Circular financing
A supplier funds a customer that then buys from it.
Neocloud
A newer company that rents out AI chips: CoreWeave, Nebius, IREN.
Hyperscaler capex
What the big cloud companies spend on data centers.
Picks and shovels
Buy the suppliers, not the companies that make the AI.
Powered land
A site with a grid connection, which is now the scarce thing.
Digital landlord
A former bitcoin miner that leases data-center space.
Take or pay
A contract paid whether or not the capacity is used.
Private credit
Lenders that are not banks, funding data centers.
No moat
Customers can switch from one model to another easily.
Open weight
A model anyone can download. Most are Chinese.
Exit liquidity
Ordinary buyers whose purchases let insiders sell.
Token maxxing
Staff running up AI usage to look productive.

How much of the investing conversation is about AI?

More every year, and sharply more in the last few months.

Posts about AI as a share of every post we read on the four networks, by month. This one counts posts, not engagement, and includes passing mentions.

How bearish is the conversation about AI stocks?

A second measure, with no language model in it. Rumor's sentiment model scores every post about the 50 companies in our AI theme, Nvidia, Microsoft, Micron and CoreWeave among them. The bars are the bearish share of the engagement on bullish and bearish posts, by month. The latest month is not complete.

How was this measured?

  • We read 1.7 billion posts on the four networks and kept the 9.7 million that mention AI, the companies that make it, or data centers, after removing duplicates and spam.
  • Most of those are not really about AI: a passing mention, a bot signature, a crypto coin with AI in its name. A language model marked those and they are left out.
  • The model read a sample of the rest and recorded, for each post, the side its author takes on the AI trade, what the author thinks of the technology, the arguments made and the stocks named.
  • Every share on this page is a share of engagement: each post counts once, plus once for each reaction to it. The four networks are added together.
  • A share of engagement can move a long way on one widely shared post. Read the direction over several months, not one month's figure.

The figures show what people are saying, which is not the same as what is true, and they do not predict a price.

How engagement is counted. More about Rumor.io.

Make better investment decisions by listening to the crowd